A reply to Derek Philpott and Wilf Turnbull

I’ve just had a communication from that gentleman of letters Derek Philpott and his cohort, Mr Wilf Turnbull, who not long ago wrote to ‘Elvis Costello and the Attractions’ regarding anomalies they’d found in some of band’s recorded works.  Having failed to elicit a response from the song smith concerned, I have stepped in to try and help.  Our respective letters may be viewed here at Mr Turnbull’s site … though I fear many wormholes may yet be found in my Victorian analogy.

Posted in Music, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 18 Comments

18 Responses to A reply to Derek Philpott and Wilf Turnbull

  1. Paul Inglis says:

    “Wormholes” – I see what you did there!

    I particularly liked the attention to detail and … diagrams! I read Flatland many, many moons ago – so yes, your reply tickled my fancy.

    • Bruce says:

      Thanks for your comment — Carl Sagan did a good piece on Flatland many moons ago, and there’s a section on it in the movie “What the Bleep Do We Know”. It’s 150 years old now, but still as good an analogy as you’ll find anywhere.

  2. Mike Miller says:

    Well, Germany….at least it was in the neighborhood.

    • Bruce says:

      At the end of the day Germany were the best team in the tournament and deserved the trophy. There’s been a lot of good games, including Belgium v USA, and a lot of attacking football and high scores. It’s goiong to take the Brazilians some time to get over it all though. I’m pleased that van Gaal got Holland to 3rd and await his arrival at Man Utd next week 🙂

      • Mike Miller says:

        Wondering if any of the Brazil players have suddenly “disappeared”. I have heard they take their soccer pretty seriously.

      • Bruce says:

        It’s happened before — when the US beat Columbia some years ago the Columbian player who scored the “own goal” was shot on his return home. I wouldn’t fancy being David Luiz at the moment. I bet Paris Saint Germain are pleased they just spent £40 mill on him.

  3. David Witherington says:

    What a fun read! Brilliant inquiry and response. Thanks for sharing, Bruce. 🙂

  4. Mike Miller says:

    I was relieved to see you weren’t referring to my own biog, “Flathead”.

  5. gez kelly says:

    On the strength of Mr Thomas’s erudite response, I have bought myself a copy of Flatland (suitably, a flat kindle edition) to read. 🙂

  6. I think that on this occasion we may have met our match

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *